D36/100
West Carthage Tap Water Quality: Is It Safe to Drink? (2026 Report)
Serving 1,734 residents · New York
What's In West Carthage's Tap Water?
1
Contaminants Tested
0
Exceed EPA Limits
1
Above EPA Goals
1 contaminant above EPA health goals
| Contaminant | Detected | Limit (MCL) | Status |
|---|---|---|---|
Lead (90th percentile) | 0.005 mg/L | 0.015 mg/L | Above Goal |
EPA Violation History
2
Violations (last 5yr)
2
Unresolved
2
Health-Related
TIER 2Unresolved
Exceeded the Maximum Contaminant Level (running average)
When: January 1, 2022 – March 31, 2022Rule: Stage 2 DBPREnforcement: Formal — state order issuedVerify on EPA.gov
TIER 2Unresolved
Exceeded the Maximum Contaminant Level (running average)
When: October 1, 2021 – December 31, 2021Rule: Stage 2 DBPREnforcement: Formal — state order issuedVerify on EPA.gov
Understanding violation severity
Tier 1Urgent health risk. Utility must notify all customers within 24 hours.Tier 2Important health or treatment issue. Customers notified within 30 days.Tier 3Administrative or monitoring issue. Reported in the annual water quality report.
Source: EPA Safe Drinking Water Information System (SDWIS) · Updated quarterly
Water Utility Details
WEST CARTHAGE VILLAGE
Population Served
1,734
Water Source
Purchased Surface Water
System ID
NY2202349
Frequently Asked Questions About West Carthage Water
Is West Carthage tap water safe to drink?
West Carthage, New York tap water receives a grade of D (36/100), which is considered poor. 0 contaminant(s) exceed EPA maximum contaminant levels and 13 violation(s) are on record. Residents should consider using an NSF-certified water filter to reduce contaminant exposure.
What contaminants are in West Carthage's water?
Of the 1 contaminants tested in West Carthage's water supply, the most notable include Lead (90th percentile). No contaminants exceed EPA legal limits. 1 contaminant(s) exceed EPA health goals (MCLGs), which are non-enforceable targets set at levels with no known health risk.
Does West Carthage have any water quality violations?
Yes, West Carthage has 13 EPA violation(s) on record, with the most recent in 2022. Violation types include MCL, MR, TT. 12 of these are health-based violations, which are the most serious category.
Do I need a water filter in West Carthage?
West Carthage water meets EPA standards, so a filter is not strictly necessary. However, some residents prefer the added security of a water filter. EPA health goals (MCLGs) are stricter than legal limits and are set at levels with zero expected health risk. 1 contaminant(s) exceed these stricter goals.
Where does West Carthage's tap water come from?
West Carthage's drinking water is sourced from purchased surface water and supplied by WEST CARTHAGE VILLAGE. The system serves approximately 1,734 people. Surface water sources include rivers, lakes, and reservoirs.
How often is West Carthage's water tested?
Under the Safe Drinking Water Act (SDWA), water utilities are required to regularly test for over 90 contaminants. Testing frequency varies by contaminant — some are tested monthly, others quarterly or annually. West Carthage's water systems must report results to the EPA and publish an annual Consumer Confidence Report (CCR). The data on this page reflects the latest available EPA testing data.
How does West Carthage's water compare to other cities in New York?
West Carthage's water quality score of 36/100 earns a grade of D, which is considered poor. This is a concerning score that suggests significant water quality issues. Visit our New York state page to see how all cities in the state compare.
What should I do if I'm concerned about West Carthage's water quality?
If you have concerns about West Carthage's tap water, consider these steps: (1) Request your utility's annual Consumer Confidence Report for detailed local data. (2) Get your water independently tested through a state-certified laboratory. (3) Consider an NSF-certified water filter rated for the contaminants found in your area. (4) Contact your water utility (WEST CARTHAGE VILLAGE) with specific questions. (5) Report water quality issues to your state drinking water program or the EPA Safe Drinking Water Hotline at 800-426-4791.